Best of the Week
Most Popular
1. Ray Dalio: This Debt Cycle Will End Soon - John_Mauldin
2.Stock Market Dow Plunge Following Fake US - China Trade War Truce - Nadeem_Walayat
3.UK House Prices 2019 No Deal BrExit 30% Crash Warning! - Nadeem_Walayat
4.What the Oil Short-sellers and OPEC Don’t Know about Peak Shale - Andrew_Butter
5.Stock Market Crashed While the Yield Curve Inverted - Troy_Bombardia
6.More Late-cycle Signs for the Stock Market and What’s Next - Troy_Bombardia
7.US Economy Will Deteriorate Over Next Half Year. What this Means for Stocks - Troy_Bombardia
8.TICK TOCK, Counting Down to the Next Recession - James_Quinn
9.How Theresa May Put Britain on the Path Towards BrExit Civil War - Nadeem_Walayat
10.This Is the End of Trump’s Economic Sugar High - Patrick_Watson
Last 7 days
UK House Prices Momentum Forecast 2019 - 18th Dec 18
Will US Government Shutdown Cause The Stock Market To Crash? - 18th Dec 18
The Coming Financial Storm - 18th Dec 18
Jeff Gundlach thinks that a Stocks Bear Market has started. Is he Right? - 18th Dec 18
Gold’s Not An Investment – You Won’t Get Rich - 17th Dec 18
Stock Market At Medium-Term Lows, Which Direction is Next? - 17th Dec 18
This Stock Will Drive America’s 5G Buildout - 17th Dec 18
Stock Market Turn In The Tide - Have a Happy Bear Market! - 17th Dec 18
How A NASA Scientist Could Trigger The Next Cannabis Boom - 17th Dec 18
iShares Russell 2000 IWM Leading Stock Market Decline - 17th Dec 18
Where is the Dow Stock Market Santa Rally? - 17th Dec 18
With Weaker Climate Consensus, Expect Elevated Climate Change - 16th Dec 18
SMIGGLE Advent Calendar 2018 UK Contents - What You Get Look Inside Review - 16th Dec 18
Is there a Lump of Coal in Santa's Stock Market Bag? - 16th Dec 18
This Market Will Drive Gold in 2019… - 16th Dec 18
Gerald Celente:Central Banks Can’t Stop a 2019 Debt Disaster - 16th Dec 18
Gold Stocks Triple Breakout - 15th Dec 18
The stock market fails to rally each day. What’s next for stocks - 14th Dec 18
How Low Could the S&P 500 Go? - 14th Dec 18
An Industrial to Stock Trade: Is Boeing a BUY Here? - 14th Dec 18
Will the Arrest of Huawei Executive Derail Trade War Truce? - 14th Dec 18
Trump vs the Fed: Who Wins? - 13th Dec 18
Expect Gold & Silver to Pullback Before the Next Move Higher - 13th Dec 18
Dollar Index Trends, USDJPY Setting Up - 13th Dec 18
While The Stocks Bulls Fiddle With The 'Fundamentals,' Rome Burns - 13th Dec 18
The Historic Role of Silver - 13th Dec 18
Natural Gas Price Setup for a Big Move Lower - 13th Dec 18
How to Get 20% Off Morrisons Weekly Supermarket Shopping - 13th Dec 18
Gold Price Analysis: Closer To A Significant Monetary Event - 13th Dec 18
Where is the Stock Market Santa Claus Rally? - 12th Dec 18
Politics and Economics in Times of Crisis - 12th Dec 18
Owning Precious Metals in an IRA - 12th Dec 18
Ways to Improve the Value of Your Home - 12th Dec 18
Theresa May No Confidence Vote, Next Tory Leader Betting Market Analysis and Forecasts - 12th Dec 18
Gold & Global Financial Crisis Redux - 12th Dec 18
Wow Your Neighbours With the Best Christmas Projector Lights for Holidays 2018! - 12th Dec 18
Stock Market Topping Formation as Risks Rise Around the World - 11th Dec 18
The Amazing Story of Gold to Gold Stocks Ratios - 11th Dec 18
Stock Market Medium term Bullish, But Long Term Risk:Reward is Bearish - 11th Dec 18
Is a Deleveraging Event about to Unfold in the Stock Market? - 11th Dec 18
Making Money through Property Investment - 11th Dec 18
Brexit: What Will it Mean for Exchange Rates? - 11th Dec 18
United States Facing Climate Change Severe Water Stress - 10th Dec 18
Waiting for Gold Price to Erupt - 10th Dec 18
Stock Market Key Support Being Re-Tested - 10th Dec 18
May BrExit Deal Tory MP Votes Forecast, Betting Market Analysis - 10th Dec 18
Listen to What Gold is Telling You - 10th Dec 18
The Stock Market’s Long Term Outlook is Changing - 10th Dec 18
Palladium Shortages Expose Broken Futures Markets for Precious Metals - 9th Dec 18
Is an Inverted Yield Curve Bullish for Gold? - 9th Dec 18

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

How You Could Make £2,850 Per Month

THE EWI ARGUMENT: A Critical Analysis of Robert Prechter and Elliott Wave International (March 2009-Present)

Stock-Markets / Elliott Wave Theory Jan 10, 2011 - 02:33 AM GMT

By: Steven_Vincent

Stock-Markets

Best Financial Markets Analysis ArticleSUMMARY

In this article I analyze the recent work of Robert Prechter’s “Elliott Wave International”, evaluating it in terms of the quality of epistemology, methodology, data integrity, interpretation, conclusions, recommendations and results. The analysis is limited in scope to the equities markets since March of 2009. Because of time constraints, counterpoints to much of the EWI argument can only be partially developed here, but I hope to give them a much fuller treatment in my forthcoming book, tentatively entitled, "Apocalypse Not Yet: Wave V and the End of Financialism".


The source material for this study is the Elliott Wave Theorist (EWT) and Elliott Wave Financial Forecast (EWFF) as well as numerous writings and audio and video interviews with Robert Prechter and Steve Hochberg. For the sake of simplicity this body of work will be referred to as "EWI". The author had access to only the following issues for inclusion in this review: EWT issues 09/05, 09/07, 09/11-12, 04/10-12/10 and EWFF issues 09/10-01/11. I have tried to represent the record faithfully from all available sources.

This report will be delivered in approximately 5 parts with one part released each week. It's a work in progress so this will be subject to revision along the way.

Outline of presentation:

1.Elliott Wave Analysis
2.Epistemological Methodology
3.Data: Integrity and Interpretation
4.Market Timing
5.Alternatives and Conclusions

General Summary:

EWI's Elliott Wave counts are based on an assumption that markets must have peaked at a Grand Supercyle top in 2000 or 2007. There is no consideration of an alternate bullish or bearish scenario on any time frame. It's epistemology and methodology do not qualify as analysis since all material begins with a predetermined and inviolable conclusion: deflationary depression. Rather than analysis, EWI's narrative falls under the category of an advocational argument on behalf of a conclusion. In spite of claims that EWI is a technical market analysis service, its reports are comprised primarily of conclusions about the fundamental environment. Assumptions about economic and social fundamentals drive the search for data supportive of the Grand Supercycle and deflationary depression conclusions. Data cited in support of the argument for imminent deflationary depression are in each case highly debatable in terms of relevance or validity and are frequently offset and contradicted entirely by stronger data supportive of an entirely contrary conclusion. All data points are presented to support the base deflationary depression and Grand Supercycle Top assumptions only. The result of a non-analytical, biased and advocational methodology has been consistently erroneous market timing during the period under review. EWI may ultimately be proven right in its argument for the deflationary depression model. There is a viable technical and fundamental argument in support of that view. However, sound analysis must be driven by an objective search for knowledge, understanding and truth. Within the context of a very long term bearish view, the Grand Supercycle Top may yet come but in a time frame far removed from the present and at a much higher price level.

I. Elliott Wave Analysis

EWI argues that Elliott Wave patterns in US stock indices indicate a long term top is in place:

Elliott Wave Analysis: Last month’s "Bottom Line" said, “The rally’s end should come after one more recovery high.” That push is mostly played out as we go to press; when complete, it should lead to a historic downside reversal. Minor wave 5 of Intermediate wave (C) started on November 9 at 10,929.30 in the DJIA. Fifth waves are ending waves, which means that wave 5 will complete the rally from 9614.30, the July low. And the end of the advance from July will mark the top of wave 2, the entire Primary-degree bear market rally that began in March 2009. A top of this magnitude would be entirely consistent with the multi-year extremes in sentiment and the waning upside momentum. (01/11 EWFF)

Here's a chart which replicates the most recent long term count from EWI:

Here the March 2009 low is counted as a Major Wave 1 down and the current high is counted as a partial retracement of that move for a Major Wave 2 high.

This chart replicates EWI's count of the move from the April 2010 high:

Here EWI is calling the April high as the top of a five wave "A" wave, the July bottom as the trough of a three wave "B" wave and the current high as the peak of a 5 wave "C" wave to complete Major Wave 2. Both of these charts represent viable bearish interpretations. I can't say that they should be dismissed and in fact they should be given serious consideration and in the due course of time they may indeed be proven to reflect the correct market view.

Let's look at some equally viable alternative wave counts that any good Elliott Wave analyst should be considering at this juncture. There isn't time or space here to present the full analysis behind each of these scenarios. In the course of this piece I will introduce some of the background components that support these proposed views. But in this immediate context I merely want to illustrate that there are other, viable Elliott Wave counts which should be considered.

My current preferred wave count has SPX in a Wave iii of 3 of (3) position. I suspect a subminor ii correction to the zone of the April and November highs, the 61.8% Fibonnacci retracement level of the decline from the 2007 high and the uptrend from the September bottom. If that support does hold then the market is set up for a Wave 3 move four degrees deep. Note the "1-2" punches on at least three (and potentially four) levels of order setting up a Wave 3 combination move. This is just about the most bullish Elliott Wave setup possible. Also note that the 61.8% Fibonacci level of acted as resistance in April and November and was taken out decisively in December. Once that level has been surpassed on a weekly, monthly and yearly basis the chances of a full retracement are significantly enhanced.

I'll briefly note in support of the above scenario that SPX has just seen a bull cross of the weekly 50 EMA over the 200 placing the long term moving averages in full bull market alignment. It's not uncommon for a market to accelerate in a Wave 3 advance off such a flash point.

An alternative to the above scenario places SPX at the cusp of a Wave 2 correction within a 3 of (3) rally. Wave 2 could easily retrace 50% of the move off the July low and retest the June and August peaks. Recent action seems to make this view less probable.

An intermediate term bearish yet long term bullish scenario has SPX topping now into a wave B high with a final C leg down to come to complete a large ABC flat correction from the April high. The B wave is a bit unusual in structure and for that reason among others I don't favor this scenario, but it is worth contemplating.

In my view, Elliott Wave analysis should at all times contain both bullish and bearish wave counts on multiple time frames and then alternative bull and bear counts as well. The aim is to discover the present (and potentially the future) reality of the market through analysis of its wave structures. In this way the wave principle can be a powerful tool to keep the trader on the right side of the market. EWI apparently uses its wave counts to describe its conclusions about the market, rather than drawing conclusions about the market from an actual analysis of its wave structures. Although its current count calling for an imminent Wave 3 Grand Supercycle decline is definitely feasible there are bullish counts which need to be considered as well.

In the next segment in this series, I'll look at EWI's material in light of its epistemological methodology. What is EWI's approach to the acquisition and interpretation of knowledge?

Generally these reports as well as twice weekly video reports are prepared for BullBear Trading Service members and then released to the general public on a time delayed basis.  To get immediate access just become a member.  It's easy and currently free of charge.

Disclosure: No current positions.

By Steve Vincent

http://www.thebullbear.com

Steven Vincent has been studying and trading the markets since 1998 and is a member of the Market Technicians Association. He is proprietor of BullBear Trading which provides market analysis, timing and guidance to subscribers. He focuses intermediate to long term swing trading. When he is not charting and analyzing the markets he teaches yoga and meditation in Los Angeles.

© 2010 Copyright Steven Vincent - All Rights Reserved Disclaimer: The above is a matter of opinion provided for general information purposes only and is not intended as investment advice. Information and analysis above are derived from sources and utilising methods believed to be reliable, but we cannot accept responsibility for any losses you may incur as a result of this analysis. Individuals should consult with their personal financial advisors.


© 2005-2018 http://www.MarketOracle.co.uk - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.


Comments

gideon
10 Jan 11, 18:17
not an impulse

The bullish count is wrong because the "first wave" as you have it labelled is definitely not impulsive, Its wave 2 retraced much less than 38%. Its "wave three" consisted of overlapping, messy waves, on diminishing volume, and at a lower slope than the wave 1 which preceded it. It is not in any way a proper impulse, and therefore this cannot be a new secular bull market. However, many corrective counts are possible, none of which you have discussed. I also do not think the EWI P2 scenario is accurate, but a complex corrective structure.


Mike Walsh
04 Apr 11, 20:57
Channeling

A major tenet of EWT is that channeling does not repeatedly hang onto channel lines. When they do, it might take some time. But it resolves as a corrective wave.


Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

6 Critical Money Making Rules