Best of the Week
Most Popular
1. Stock Markets and the History Chart of the End of the World (With Presidential Cycles) - 28th Aug 20
2.Google, Apple, Amazon, Facebook... AI Tech Stocks Buying Levels and Valuations Q3 2020 - 31st Aug 20
3.The Inflation Mega-trend is Going Hyper! - 11th Sep 20
4.Is this the End of Capitalism? - 13th Sep 20
5.What's Driving Gold, Silver and What's Next? - 3rd Sep 20
6.QE4EVER! - 9th Sep 20
7.Gold Price Trend Forecast Analysis - Part1 - 7th Sep 20
8.The Fed May “Cause” The Next Stock Market Crash - 3rd Sep 20
9.Bitcoin Price Crash - You Will be Suprised What Happens Next - 7th Sep 20
10.NVIDIA Stock Price Soars on RTX 3000 Cornering the GPU Market for next 2 years! - 3rd Sep 20
Last 7 days
Amazon AMZN Stock PRIMEDAY SALE! Trend Analysis - 20th Apr 21
Stock Market Sentiment Speaks: You May Not Believe My 2021 Targets - 20th Apr 21
Stock Market Phase Two Projection - 20th Apr 21
Are Precious Metals & Miners Starting A New Longer-Term Bullish Trend? - 20th Apr 21
Inflation: First the Gain, Then the Pain… - 20th Apr 21
8 Stock Market Indicators in 1: Here's the Message of the Panic/Euphoria Model - 19th Apr 21
Gold - You Can Win a Battle, but Still Lose the War - 19th Apr 21
Will Interest Rates Rally Further Push Gold Price Down? - 19th Apr 21
Gold Fireworks Doubt the Official Inflation Story - 19th Apr 21
YuanPay Team Discuss The Process Of Crypto Diversification - 19th Apr 21
Central Banks May Ramp Up Gold Buying - 18th Apr 21
How to Get Rid of Driveway Weeds With Just WATER! 6 Months later NO Weeds, Ultimate Killer! - 18th Apr 21
State of the European Markets - DAX, FTSE, CAC, AEX, SMI, IBEX 35, S&P/MIB, Euro Stoxx 50, RTS - 18th Apr 21
Einvestment Fund: What You Need To Know About Investments - 18th Apr 21
Google Alphabet (GOOG) AI Deep Mind Stock Trend Analysis - 17th Apr 21
Stocks and Bonds Inflationary Slingshot - 17th Apr 21
Best Smartphone Selfie Stick Tripod Review by ATUMTEK Works with Samsung Galaxy and Iphone - 17th Apr 21
How to Give Budgie's First Bath | Easy Budgie Bathing and Water Training with Lettuce - 17th Apr 21
Record-breaking Decrease in New Passenger Vehicle Sale in Europe - 17th Apr 21
US Stocks Climb A “Wall Of Worry” To New Highs - 16th Apr 21
Gold’s Singular Role - 16th Apr 21
See what Anatomy of a Bursting Market Bubble looks like - 16th Apr 21
Many Stock Market Sectors Are Primed For Another Breakout Rally – Are You? - 16th Apr 21
What Skyrocketing US Home Prices Say About Inflation - 16th Apr 21
Still a Bullish Fever in Stocks? - 16th Apr 21
Trying to Buy Coinbase Stock on IPO Day - Institutional Investors Freeze out Retail Investors - 15th Apr 21
Stocks or Gold – Which Is in the Catbird Seat? - 15th Apr 21
Time For A Stock Market Melt-Up - 15th Apr 21
Stocks Bull Market Progression Now Shows Base Metal Strength - 15th Apr 21
AI Tech Stocks Buy Ratings, Levels and Valuations - 14th Apr 21
Easy 10% to 15% Overclock for 5600x, 5900x, 5950x Using AMD Ryzen Master Precision Boost Overdrive - 14th Apr 21
The Current Cannabis Sector Rally Is Pointing To Another Breakout - 14th Apr 21
U.S. Dollar Junk Bond Market The Easiest Money in History - 14th Apr 21
The SPY Is Nearing Resistance @ $410… What Is Next? - 14th Apr 21
The Curious Stock Market Staircase Rally - 14th Apr 21
Stocks are Heating Up - 14th Apr 21
Two Methods in Calculating For R&D Tax Credits - 14th Apr 21
Stock Market Minor Correction Due - 13th Apr 21
How to Feed Budgies Cucumbers - Best Vegetables Feeding for the First Time, Parakeet Care UK - 13th Apr 21
Biggest Inflation Threat in 40 Years Looms over Markets - 13th Apr 21
How to Get Rich with the Pareto Distribution - Tesco Example - 13th Apr 21
Litecoin and Bitcoin-Which Is Better? - 13th Apr 21
The Major Advantages Of Getting Your PhD Online - 12th Apr 21
Covid-19 Pandemic Current State for UK, US, Europe, Brazil Vaccinations vs Lockdown's Third Wave - 12th Apr 21
Why These Stock Market Indicators Should Grab Your Full Attention - 12th Apr 21
Rising Debt Means a Weaker US Dollar - 12th Apr 21
Another Gold Stocks Upleg - 12th Apr 21
AMD The ZEN Tech Stock - 12th Apr 21
Overclockers UK Build Quality - Why Glue Fan to CPU Heat sink Instead of Using Supplied Clips? - 12th Apr 21 -
What are the Key Capabilities You Should Look for in Fleet Management Software? - 12th Apr 21
What Is Bitcoin Gold? - 12th Apr 21
UK Covd-19 FREE Lateral Flow Self Testing Kits How Use for the First Time at Home - 10th Apr 21
NVIDIA Stock ARMED and Dangeorus! - 10th Apr 21
The History of Bitcoin Hard Forks - 10th Apr 21
Gold Mining Stocks: A House Built on Shaky Ground - 9th Apr 21
Stock Market On the Verge of a Pullback - 9th Apr 21
What Is Bitcoin Unlimited? - 9th Apr 21
Most Money Managers Gamble With Your Money - 9th Apr 21
Top 5 Evolving Trends For Mobile Casinos - 9th Apr 21
Top 5 AI Tech Stocks Investing 2021 Analysis - 8th Apr 21
Dow Stock Market Trend Forecast 2021 - Crash or Continuing Bull Run? - 8th Apr 21
Don’t Be Fooled by the Stock Market Rally - 8th Apr 21
Gold and Latin: Twin Pillars of Western Rejuvenation - 8th Apr 21
Stronger US Dollar Reacts To Global Market Concerns – Which ETFs Will Benefit? Part II - 8th Apr 21
You're invited: Spot the Next BIG Move in Oil, Gas, Energy ETFs - 8th Apr 21
Ladies and Gentlemen, Mr US Dollar is Back - 8th Apr 21
Stock Market New S&P 500 Highs or Metals Rising? - 8th Apr 21
Microsoft AI Azure Cloud Computing Driving Tech Giant Profits - 7th Apr 21
Amazon Tech Stock PRIMEDAY SALE- 7th Apr 21
The US has Metals Problem - Lithium, Graphite, Copper, Nickel Supplies - 7th Apr 21
Yes, the Fed Will Cover Biden’s $4 Trillion Deficit - 7th Apr 21
S&P 500 Fireworks and Gold Going Stronger - 7th Apr 21
Stock Market Perceived Vs. Actual Risks: The Key To Success - 7th Apr 21

Market Oracle FREE Newsletter

FIRST ACCESS to Nadeem Walayat’s Analysis and Trend Forecasts

Making Green Energy Credible

Commodities / Renewable Energy Jan 21, 2012 - 12:34 PM GMT

By: Andrew_McKillop

Commodities

Best Financial Markets Analysis ArticleCan we make green energy credible ? Not so much a victim of its own succees, but victim of its own failure, green energy still hangs on and hangs in among the mix-and-mingle of dominant government and elite ideologies in most OECD countries, and several G20 and Emerging economies led by China and India. One reason for this is really basic: there are no other ideas on the subject of "After we run out of cheap oil, what do we do ?"


We only have to ask - with no answer - what happens to oil supply and prices when or if China and India achieved the current OECD consumption average of more than 14 barrels per person, per year.
Currently on less than 3 barrels/person/year for China, and below 2 barrels/person/year for India, their combined demand, at today's OECD average rate, would be almost equal to world total oil demand in 2012, and would be around 85 million barrels/day. Their current combined demand is 12.5 Mbd. Other Emerging countries would also raise their oil burn with economic growth, but nobody serious, starting with the IEA and EIA says world oil supply can be raised by 70 Mbd in the next 35 years to 2045.

Conversely or alternatively, we could play with the idea of King Coal saving the planet: if the world's 7 billion consumers used coal at the Chinese rate of about 1.75 tons/person/year (or the US rate of 3 tons) world coal demand would spiral up from its current 6 bn tons per year, to reserve-threatening heights, let alone climate change threatening heights !

So the "missing energy" has to come from somewhere else. Oil is the shortest-fuze resources, making it possible to ask if the Chinese and Indians will be content to own and use 10 or 12 times fewer cars per thousand population, than the "postindustrial" countries of the OECD group ? We can keep on dreaming, while they keep on trucking !

For at least the past 5 years, talk about Energy Transition to Green Energy as a critical challenge to civilization was standard teleprompter material for high profile persons like Obama, Merkel, Sarkozy, plus a certain number of "great statesmen" of the retired, failed or thrown out variety, such as Gorbachev, Al Gore or Tony Blair. These days Obama, Merkel and Sarkozy are more concerned about keeping their place atop the greasy pole and fending off international bankruptcy than talking about what Obama called "the Sputnik Moment", when green energy starts to Save The Planet. Daily proof rolls in that weaning consumer society off oil (cheap or otherwise) is a hopeless quest, the process takes too long, the real alternatives like coal are not easy to ramp up, and expecting the market to handle an epic and massive Green Energy Transition is like trying to save Lehman Bros or MF Global.

DIRE THINGS
This in no way stops the highest possible level of ex-deciders and great statesmen, such as Gorbachev, Gore and Blair, and the Club of Madrid Worldshift Network's team of former presidents and PMs, former NATO chiefs, and a gaggle of present billionaires, advised by a star-studded lineup of experts, from predicting dire things for the human race unless fossil energy is completely abandoned.

The storyline has not changed with shale gas or anything else. The Network goes on forecasting very dire things.

Their material does not cut around the corners. They say fossil energy (oil, coal, gas) has to be not just shaded down, or blended into green energy, but radically and totally phased out. Mikhail Gorbachev, heading the Club of Madrid's 2009 climate initiative has plenty of times gone on record, saying the world needs a 50% cut in fossil energy consumption by 2020 - 2025. This would be a cut of 45 Mbd simply for oil, and a cut of over 3 billion tons a year for coal. The European Union's climate-energy policy and its national programmes, for as long as they last, has targets that are not far behind Gorbachev Goals, with a 20% cut being set for the 8-year period to 2020. For Germany, the target is a 40% cut on 2005 levels of CO2 emissions (ie levels of fossil energy consumption) by 2020.

Are these goals achievable ? Since they probably are not feasible, why are they being touted by persons who (normally speaking) try to stay credible ? Are they suffering from elite collective hysteria ?

Or schizophrenia: what has to be the most "dirigiste" possible plan or programme - to totally phase out fossil energy - is also and supposedly market friendly for creating the industrial capacity and deploying the new/alternate energy eqipment and infrastructures. Practically unaided, the hedge fund fraternity can lever this massive transition, we are told. There is no need for clumsy, complex and unproductive bureaucratic meddling in energy. To make this clear the world's one and only, bureaucratic and clumsy, mandatory carbon emissions market system, the ETS in Europe, which shuffled about $40 billion of tradable carbon paper in 2011, is set for a hefty fall in turnover in 2012. Among the reasons for this is simple loss of credibility. ETS ran out of luck and tolerance. The strange mix-and-mingle of ideologies on offer for achieving Energy Transition (or instead, experiencing Apocalypse Now) then shifts to the other extreme of the spectrum. This features Silicon Valley-type feel good investing - in failed start ups - as a nice way to burn up cash and waste economic resources, producing little or nothing.

We might imagine Gorbachev will give us a break from telling the world to abandon fossil energy, and go back to telling us to buy Pizza Hut food products, but we have no answers to our questions.

GOELRO GOES GREEN
Due to media brainwashing, most persons think "green energy" equals windmills, solar power plants and perhaps biofuels. In fact at least one-half of all current non-fossil energy is hydropower and biomass fuel buring for power plants, but this brings up one critical point. The basic pillar of green energy development is that electricity dominates what comes out of the projects which actually get built. Wind, solar, hydro and most biomass fuels used in developed countries (eg Europe and USA) are used to produce electricity.

Biofuels able to save oil sound nice, to be sure, but production has peaked out already at around 60 billion litres/year split between Brazil and the USA. This is at most 4% of world automobile and truck fuel demand, which is growing, while biofuels output is not. The US EIA, obediently reflecting White House feeling on the subject forecasts mindboggling volumes of future biofuels production in the USA, "about 2035", especially non-food cellulose ethanol and other biofuels. Today however, green energy "as we know it" means electricity. At least two-thirds of all the coal burned, today, is also used to produce electricity, and over one-half of all gas consumption is to produce electricity, so green energy is a semi-rational alternative and substitute for coal and gas, if not oil.

Lenin's, and then Stalin's GOELRO plans were founded in the 1920s with the same urgency as Gorbachev's call for total Energy Transition in 2009, if not his calls for Pizza Hut eat-outs around 2000, and featured the same magic one size fits all answer to future energy: electricity.

Later called Five Year Plans, the GOELRO all-electric energy plan of the early Soviet Union was at least as unsuccessful as an average Silicon Valley green energy start-up, or European ETS carbon trading, in producing real world on-the-ground new energy supplies. What counted for the Soviets, and counts for hand-on-heart modern capitalist Market Libs is an overlay of ideological euphoria, covering government handouts to the Happy Few - who then throw it away.

Just like GOELRO, whipping the media into a frenzy of Apocalypse Now, the Low Carbon hysteria of about 2006-2010 is totally unproductive: there is no change on the ground, and nothing happens. However, in GOELRO times, the USSR was set way back on the curve of oil reserve discovery, development and depletion, with at least 225 billion barrels of future low cost conventional oil reserves to extract and consume: today's Russian conventional oil reserves remaining to extract are anywhere from 60 to 130 - 140 bn barrels, and current production, called a record at about 10.25 Mbd (3.75 bn barrels per year) is in fact far behind the 1988 peak of 12.5 Mbd.

Russia will have to find a lot more oil, fast, to keep its output at more than 10 Mbd, meaning that oil saving either already interests Russia, or will soon interest Russia.

Exactly the same applies to No. 2 world producer Saudi Arabia. The next stage on from this stage for both of them is simple: Russian and Saudi production will be capped to conserve national reserves. This can be presented as a political decision, or a technical decision driven by geological realities, or decided to bolster and maintain oil prices and national revenues at a high level, but any potential for regime change through military invasion - to "tweak up production" - is an unlikely sequel. Certainly for Russia, although maybe not impossible for Saudi Arabia if it unilaterally declared it was downsizing its oil production to say 7.5 or 8 Mbd and capping it there, right now, to conserve national oil reserves.

DOWNSIZING WILL BE RADICAL
What we face is a likely stagnation of world fossil energy supply - stagnation then decline for oil, slow growth and possible stagnation of coal supply, but growth of gas thanks to shale gas. We also can fear there will be low rates of replacement of fossil energy with green energy, because investment performance was, and is so bad. For China, this is now open policy. China Briefing for 21 Jan 2012 reports: while the country originally had plans to invest up to US$1.5 trillion over the next five years in seven strategic sectors (including) high-end equipment manufacturing, alternative energy, biotechnology, alternative fuel cars, energy-saving and environmentally friendly technology, China is now more worried about the return on such investments.

According to Bloomberg New Energy Finance, total investment and spending (the two being far apart !) in green energy and cleantech through 2006-2011 surpassed a total of $1 trillion. The problem was that energy results on the ground are so small we do not even have to talk about them.

Announced on 9 January by Germany's economics minister Roesler, the former poster child of German green energy - solar photovoltaic power - is set for serious and sombre shrinkage. Cuts in subsidies to the industry as feed-in tariffs, grants, tax breaks, employee training, factory facilities, raw materials discounts, even exchange rate risk cover for exports, and other state support, may be so deep and so far that in Roesler's view annual German installations could fall from 7.5 GW in 2011, to around 3.5 GW in 2012 and as little as 1 GW per year in 2013-14. Chinese plans for downsizing their solar PV industry are at least as radical: cuts mulled by the state energy planning bureau are for reducing annual production capacity of 70 GW that China would have achieved in 2013-14, on current fast rates of growth, to as little as 20 GW of annual production capacity.

These are cuts of 70% - 85% in 3 years, and a similar if not-so-steep decline of capacity for world windpower production is almost certain. Early signs of trouble are centred on the world's No. 1 windmill producer Vestas of Denmark, and another overlevered European producer, Gamesa of Spain. Showing this is worldwide industry retrenchment and shrinkage, Suzlon of India, Goldwind, Sinovel and Dongfang of China, and GE of the USA are also experiencing major falls in windpower sales and profitability. The only real hope of world windpower is offshore windfarms - if somebody pays.

The read out is simple: fossil energy investment is now high cost and low return except in highly specific niches and sectors, possibly but not certainly including stranded gas and shale gas - but green energy investing is even worse: the industry grew too fast on the back of government subsidies and lack of international planning, coordination and control. Its credibility fell as its many limits have become clear, including its financing. The only advantage of the Market Lib model, if it is one, is that the fragile boom of 2006-2010 is changing fast to bust -  and not need Stalin-type show trials to kick whipping boys into the grave. The end result for consumers, taxpayers and voters is exactly the same: no energy transition, sure and certain higher energy prices, wasted resources and wasted time. The clock ticks on.

By Andrew McKillop

Contact: xtran9@gmail.com

Former chief policy analyst, Division A Policy, DG XVII Energy, European Commission. Andrew McKillop Biographic Highlights

Andrew McKillop has more than 30 years experience in the energy, economic and finance domains. Trained at London UK’s University College, he has had specially long experience of energy policy, project administration and the development and financing of alternate energy. This included his role of in-house Expert on Policy and Programming at the DG XVII-Energy of the European Commission, Director of Information of the OAPEC technology transfer subsidiary, AREC and researcher for UN agencies including the ILO.

© 2012 Copyright Andrew McKillop - All Rights Reserved Disclaimer: The above is a matter of opinion provided for general information purposes only and is not intended as investment advice. Information and analysis above are derived from sources and utilising methods believed to be reliable, but we cannot accept responsibility for any losses you may incur as a result of this analysis. Individuals should consult with their personal financial advisors.


© 2005-2019 http://www.MarketOracle.co.uk - The Market Oracle is a FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.


Post Comment

Only logged in users are allowed to post comments. Register/ Log in

6 Critical Money Making Rules